The protein shelf · how we score
Every number, and where it came from.
Each figure on the shelf comes from one of two places: the product's label data, or Koala's scoring engine, the same code the app runs when you scan a barcode. Here's how, so you can decide how much to trust it.
Who it's scored for
A few bites at a time.
One person, the same for every product: on a GLP-1, no side effects, eating a few bites at a time, with no shot day given, so the days after a shot never come into it. That's a day of 120 g of protein across 4 small meals: 30 g and about 300 calories a meal.
The engine reads each serving as a meal, a snack or a sip. Anything you drink is a sip. Otherwise it goes by the serving's share of a meal's calories: up to about 40% (120 calories here) is a snack, more than that is a meal. A meal is measured against the whole 30 g, a snack or a sip against half. On this list 56 read as a meal, 10 as a snack and 34 as a sip, so most bars are judged as a small meal.
"Queasy" runs the same product again for the same person with nausea, and nothing else changed. Nausea makes fat count double and moves weight from Protein to Gentle, so a few products climb on a queasy day and some drop.
In the app you answer these questions yourself and it scores for your answers, so your word there can differ from the word here.
What the word means
One word, out of 100.
The score is four parts, each out of 100, weighted for this person:
- Protein (41%). How much of the meal's protein a serving covers, and how much protein it carries per 100 calories.
- Gentle (29%). What a slow stomach will struggle with. Fat, saturated fat, sugar, sugar alcohols, fizz, caffeine and additives each take points off. Under 25 here and it can't score above Not today, however much protein it has.
- Fiber and fullness (18%). Fiber against a meal's share, and how lightly processed it is.
- Nutrients (12%). Calcium, iron, potassium and magnesium per 100 calories, and how complete the protein is.
On a queasy day the four are weighted 31%, 39%, 18% and 12%.
The first sort
Most protein for the calories.
The label's protein divided by its calories, times 100, from the same figures the score reads. It says how much of what you manage to get down is protein, whatever the serving size.
Where the figures come from
The label, checked twice.
Each barcode is looked up the way the app's scanner does it: Open Food Facts first, with USDA FoodData Central as a second opinion. When the two disagree on protein, USDA wins. On this run USDA agreed on 70 products, and had no record of 30. Those rest on Open Food Facts alone, and each one says so.
A figure neither database gives is shown as missing, with what that did to the score. Nothing is filled in. The gaps that come up most are sugar alcohols (91 products), magnesium (74 products), calcium (16 products), iron (14 products). US records rarely give sugar alcohols as a number; when the ingredients name one anyway, the engine takes off a set amount. A missing mineral counts as middling, not zero and not full.
The filters treat unknown as no. "No artificial sweeteners" shows only products whose ingredient list was read and named none. Labels change and the databases are kept by people, so treat every figure as close, not exact. Scored 11 November 2026.
What we judged by hand
And what the code worked out.
- Which products we scored. Their names and their type, too. It started from the brands people name most and the shakes, bars and powders on our own store list. Of the 116 we scored, the shelf shows the 100 with the highest Koala score. The download has them all.
- Clear, not milky and something savory are tags we set by hand. Clear: Isopure Clear whey isolate; Isopure Infusions clear whey isolate; Protein2o Protein water; Protein2o Protein drink, cherry lemonade. Savory: Quest Protein chips, chili lime; Quest Protein chips, spicy sweet chili; Quest Protein chips, BBQ; Quest Protein chips, ranch; Quest Protein chips, hot and spicy; Quest Protein chips, nacho cheese; Quest Protein chips, loaded taco.
- Stores. A store shows only with the month it was checked. 87 products carry stores, each checked for that brand's line at that store, not for every flavor. 13 have no store checked yet and say so.
- Held back. A product whose record is plainly wrong is left unscored and named with the reason, rather than shown with figures we know are off.
- Worked out by code. Artificial sweeteners (sucralose, acesulfame K, aspartame, saccharin, neotame, advantame) and dairy are read from the ingredient and allergen lists. Sugar alcohols, fizz and caffeine are read by the engine. "3 g fiber or more" is per serving, the point where the app calls a food good for staying regular.
Credit, and who makes it
Open data, and an app we sell.
Nutrition data comes from Open Food Facts, under the Open Database License, and from USDA FoodData Central, which is public domain. The downloadable list is offered under the same Open Database License. Spot a wrong record? Fixing it on Open Food Facts fixes it here on the next run.
Koala makes this page, and the app it points to is ours. No brand or store pays for a place on the shelf or a better word.
It's a nutrition reference, not medical advice, and it hasn't been reviewed by a dietitian yet. Questions about how much you need, or about your medication, belong with your prescriber. Something wrong? Write to anonymous@actualoccasions.com.